Labeled. Typecast. Stuck.

Told to be shorter or taller, younger or older, funnier, prettier. Told

your time will come.

We want to get unstuck, to find our own unique ways to use theater to engage with the world around us.


We want to give theater artists the chance to make the work they want to make, not the work the industry tells them they should be making.

Founded in December 2016, Pigeonholed is a non-profit theater company based in NYC and founded by NYU Tisch classmates Sasha Lazare and Justin Cimino. Our first production was "Detroit," by Lisa D'Amour, at the IATI Theater in March 2017, directed by Lauren Z. Adleman.

In Spring 2018 we opened our Education wing (head over to the "Education" tab to find out more!)


For the past four years we have produced full seasons of work. Head over to the "Productions" tab for more.

Justin Cimino - Todd Estrin Photography-

Justin received his BFA in Drama from NYU’s Tisch School of the Arts, training at the Meisner Studio. He has trained at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art in London. As an actor, he has performed Off-Broadway and in many other productions in NYC. He has workshopped solo work under Austin Pendleton at The Directors Company. He has been a teaching artist for 15 years. He is currently the Education Director and Operations Manager for Zara Aina, a nonprofit organization that brings theater to at-risk communities in Madagascar and the United States. He was hired by UNICEF to use Zara Aina’s theater work to mobilize communities in Madagascar to fight polio. He has devised, written, and directed several original shows based on Malagasy folktales with Zara Aina’s Malagasy Youth Company. He has brought Zara Aina’s work to rural Southern Alabama, building original pageant-style shows with community members ages 4-84. Justin has directed and taught clowning and the devised “moment work” of the Tectonic Theater Project at NYU Tisch, Columbia University, the Studio/NY, and The Public’s Shakespeare Initiative. Recently Justin devised, wrote, and directed documentary theater pieces about a Jackson Heights hoarder, a triple amputee who runs a Hospice Center, and a 90-year-old woman who used to hunt Nazis. In the spring of 2019, Justin received a SU-CASA grant from the Queens Council on the Arts to build an original piece of theater with senior citizens in Queens.




Lindsey holds a dual concentration degree from the University of Michigan's School of Music, Theater, & Dance in Stage Management and Theater Education. She has taught and directed theater for children of all ages, most recently directing an adaptation of Stuart Little. Lindsey served as a founding member and Director of Education for ProjectSOAR, a non-profit to promote arts education in under funded schools. She also facilitated rehabilitative theater classes for incarcerated men, specializing in devising new work. Selected Stage Management credits: #yourmemorial (Pigeonholed); The Glass Menagerie (Pigeonholed); Blood at the Root (Michigan Premiere); Sunday in the Park With George (Interlochen) Insurrection: Holding History (University of Michigan). 

Sasha Lazare.jpg

Sasha holds a BFA in Drama from NYU’s Tisch School of the Arts with a minor in Applied Theatre. Favorite roles include Kayleen in Gruesome Playground Injuries, the title role in Mary Stuart, and Lady 2 in EVE, as well as various film and TV roles. She teaches children’s theatre classes throughout Brooklyn and is the Associate Director of the Intermediate Acting Company at Interlochen Arts Camp. She also has a dog named Eloise and will show you a photo if you ask politely.

Photo credit: Gabriel Frye-Behar

Associated Artists

Sammy Jelinek

Susannah Hyde

Allison Houser

Emily Hawkins

Maggie Hood

Nettie Chickering

Rashidah Bernay Fowler

Fiona Rae Brunner

Caitlin Cimino

Emily Rellis

Marlena Holman

Lauren Z. Adleman

Zoë Adams

Katie Fanning

Justin Fuller

Casey Worthington

Isabelle Coler

Sam Froeschle

Kelley Shih

Morgan Leigh Beach

Morgan Grambo

Gabriel Frye-Behar

Alice Rothman-Hicks

Alana Fu

Adam Foldes

Tomas Virgadula

Jameson Lisak

Brian Simmons

Kelsey Coughlin

Mariel Matero

Megan Magee

Zach Rich

Lawrence Lazare

Matthew Tyler

Pat Reidy

Lou Patane

Paul Lombardo

Rachel Denise April

E.L. Hohn

Cheyenne Sykes